Retraining brains HOPE AFTER INJURIES, ILLNESSES
August 2nd, 2010.
Douglas native Raymond Gould, 27, and his mother, Carol Gould, of Fitchburg, interact in Raymond’s room at St. Mary Health Care Center in Worcester. Mr. Gould is recovering from brain surgery. These should be the prime years of Raymond Gould’s life. Until last November, the 27-year old waiter’s life was full of friends, good times, dancing and music. g
, dancing and.
His life changed forever when a sinus infection traveled to his brain. With his brain swelling dangerously, he lapsed into a coma for six weeks and had three surgeries to reduce the swelling. He has since navigated a slow, painful recovery. Last week, the young man who had coached the color guard at Douglas High School and dreamed of competing on the television show “So You Think You Can Dance?” moved into a nursing home, St. Mary Health Care Center in Worcester.
“He’s a little frustrated, realizing where he is,” said his mother, Carol Gould of Fitchburg. “I didn’t want him in a nursing home, but there are so few options out there for someone with a brain injury like Ray’s.”But those options may improve in the next year or two as the state implements a settlement agreement reached in a federal class action lawsuit brought on behalf of Massachusetts residents with both traumatic and acquired brain injuries. The settlement may help Mr. Gould and others like him to leave institutions and live in the community.
On his third day at St. Mary last week, Mr. Gould, who needs a wheelchair because he has trouble standing, seemed a bit down. He answered every question in the negative, with a shake of his head. He refused to speak more than his name, although his mother said he can chat on his cell phone. He clenched his hands. When he got upset, he tapped his fists against his thighs.
His dark mood lifted, however, when his sister April and his 4-month-old nephew, Logan, arrived for a visit. He broke into a smile. Holding Logan in his arms, he said, “Hi buddy.” He kissed the baby on the forehead. Despite his frustrations at his body’s betrayal, Mr. Gould has managed to keep his sense of humor, his mother said. One night they were praying, as is their habit when Ms. Gould takes her leave of her son every night. “God, hear our prayers,” she ended. “God, don’t listen to my mother,” he said.
Ms. Gould said she is eternally thankful that St. Mary accepted her son, and said the staff has been incredibly supportive. Still, Mr. Gould hasn’t exactly rushed out of his room to play bingo with his elderly hall mates. He pretty much keeps to himself. Following his stay at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital in Boston, going home or moving into his own apartment proved impossible. There was nothing available.
“The options are limited. There really aren’t that many facilities that specialize in treating brain injuries,” said Arlene Korab, executive director of the Westboro-based Brain Injury Association of Massachusetts. “Recovering from brain injuries is a very long, prolonged rehabilitation. You need continuous therapies to retrain the brain to do what it used to.”
There are services for the very young, the very old and those who suffer from traumatic brain injury, which is caused by a blow to the head. Besides institutions, there are group homes and some limited at-home support services.
But for young people with an acquired brain injury such as Mr. Gould’s, the only current option is a nursing home or rehabilitative facility. “You get a young person sitting there with senior citizens; it’s a whole different way of living,” Ms. Korab said. “A lot of them get depressed.”
Mr. Gould’s friends have been holding numerous fundraisers on his behalf, but the costs of his rehabilitation are staggering. He did not have health insurance before he fell ill and is now covered by MassHealth, the state’s Medicaid health insurance program. Ms. Gould said her son’s health care coverage has limited his care options and suspects that St. Mary will lose money by treating him. She lost her job as a sales representative as she stayed by his side and navigated the health care system on his behalf.
The recent settlement of the federal class action lawsuit may someday offer Mr. Gould and his mother hope. The first-in-the-nation lawsuit, Hutchinson v. Patrick, was filed in 2007 by the Brain Injury Association of Massachusetts and five patients with brain injuries. The lawsuit accused the state of violating the federal Americans with Disabilities Act by keeping brain injury patients in institutions — even after their doctors say they no longer need to be in a nursing facility — because no services exist to help them live with family or on their own.
The lawsuit demanded that the state and federal government pay for community services for nearly 2,000 Massachusetts residents with brain injuries who currently live in nursing homes and rehabilitative facilities. “I think about the residents (with brain injuries)… and I know what their empty lives are like,” wrote Cathy Hutchinson, 55, of Attleboro, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit. After a brainstem stroke in 1996 left her a mute quadriplegic, she spent 11 years in a nursing home.
“Sometimes,” she wrote in an e-mail, “I feel like I am in prison for a crime I didn’t commit. I need to start living my life, instead of just existing in a wheelchair.” For many years, treatment and therapy for brain injury patients was largely nonexistent because it was believed patients did not recover, said Dr. Jean McGuire, assistant secretary for disability policy and programs with the Executive Office of Health and Human Services. That idea has changed, especially because so many more people now survive serious brain injuries.
“This is not the first time that the state’s response was dictated by a settlement,” Dr. McGuire said. “We’re proceeding to build the services for people who want to come out of institutions and live in the community. We’re going into uncharted territory, and there’s going to be a lot to learn about what is the right mix of services.”
The settlement of the Hutchinson case will help Medicaid-eligible residents of nursing homes and rehab facilities who acquired their brain injury through a traumatic event such as an accident or through a stroke, poisoning or, like Mr. Gould, a disease.
Under the settlement agreement, which is still subject to court approval, the state will create two waiver programs designed to transition individuals with brain injuries out of nursing facilities and other institutions into community residences. The programs must be approved by the federal government, which will pay half the cost.
The program will be implemented over several years, but should result in approximately 200 to 250 persons a year leaving nursing facilities. Dr. McGuire said it will likely be a year before the first brain injury patients begin to move from institutions to community settings.
Before then, Mr. Gould will most likely need another placement. His MassHealth plan has agreed to pay for his stay at St. Mary through September. What happens then? “I guess we’ll see,” Ms. Gould said.
Source: TELEGRAM & GAZETTE STAFF - Aaron Nicodemus 06.06.2010